Accidental
Associations

Accidental Associations

Research

In 1980 Charles Jencks handed a questionnaire to passers-by outside the Olivetti Centre in England and asked them what a building made them think of. In 1920 Wassily Kandinsky had handed out a nearly identical questionnaire at INKhUK in revolutionary Moscow. Kandinsky used the answers to search for a universal language of form; Jencks used them to show plurality. The research studies the association of ideas as a method that philosophers, architects, critics and psychologists used to explain how a form comes to mean something. John Locke described the mind’s habit of connecting ideas in his Essay concerning Human Understanding. Archibald Alison built a theory of taste on it in 1790, and John Claudius Loudon turned that theory into a method of architectural criticism in the Architectural Magazine (1834–1838). Jeremy Bentham and James Mill derived pleasure, habit and education from the laws of association. John Stuart Mill and Auguste Comte argued over its place among the sciences in their letters of 1841 to 1847. In Leipzig, Gustav Theodor Fechner and Wilhelm Wundt took association into the laboratory, and Heinrich Wölfflin’s Prolegomena of 1886 adopted Fechner’s results and left association out. In the 1920s the Constructivists at INKhUK set out to erase existing associations and build new ones, the Purists of L’Esprit Nouveau reduced form until only the general remained, and the Surrealists in Paris let associations drift. Kandinsky’s encyclopedia of form stayed unfinished, Paul Otlet’s Mundaneum was never built, and Le Corbusier failed Nikolai Ladovsky’s perception test in Moscow.